|The Long-Range Impact of the Recession on Families|
A Report Prepared for the 13th Annual Conference of the Council on Contemporary Families, Augustana College, April 16-17, 2010
By Valerie Adrian and Stephanie Coontz
The economy is now out of free fall, but the impact of recent economic losses on families will continue for many years to come. An overview of the economic, unemployment and poverty trends suggests why:
The expanded unemployment benefits, increased food stamp allowances, and additional tax credits passed by Congress are estimated to have saved 6 million Americans from falling into poverty. But although new poverty figures will not be released into August, many other indicators point to a significant rise over the past year. And even before the recession, the number of poor people climbed by 15 percent between 2000 and 2008, wiping out the gains of the 1990s. America's suburbs saw the biggest increase, with the number of poor people jumping by 25 percent. By 2008, according to the Brookings Institution, one-third of the nation's poor lived in suburbs, most of which lack the emergency shelters and social services such found in urban areas.
Although lower housing prices in some areas opened up access to individuals and families that could not previously afford them, foreclosures and evictions continue. As of November 2009, one in seven mortgages was delinquent. By March 2010, one in four people were "under water"; that is, they owed more on their mortgages than their houses were worth on the market. According to Moody's Economy.com, even if the administration's new anti-foreclosure measure prevents 1.5 million foreclosures by 2012, another 3.6 million homes will be lost by that date.
FEELING THE PINCH ON BASIC NECESSITIES
THE HUMAN COSTS OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND ECONOMIC STRESS
A recent National Bureau of Economic Research working paper looked at the mortality rates of men who had lost their jobs in earlier recessions and found a 15 to 20 percent increase in death rates during the next 20 years. A man who lost his job at age 30 was on average likely to die a year-and-half earlier than a man who was steadily employed. A study of plant closures in Sweden reported a 44 percent increase in the mortality risk among men during the first four years following the loss of a job.
Suicide hotlines across the country have seen a spike in calls, from 39,000 in January 2009 to 57,000 in July, with 30 percent of the increase directly related to the economy, according to Richard McKeon, lead adviser for suicide prevention for the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration.
Even among workers who retain their jobs, pay cuts and fears of job loss take a huge toll. The Families and Work Institute's ongoing National Study of the Changing Workforce shows that economic insecurity is the number one predictor of overall health problems, more frequent signs of depression, sleep difficulties, and stress among employed workers. Unemployment takes an even more severe toll on people's health. In the NYT/CBS poll, 55 percent of laid-off workers reported that their unemployment triggered insomnia. Almost half said that it had led to conflicts with family members or friends. Women were more likely than men to admit to anxiety or depression as a result of job loss, but men were more likely to report feeling ashamed most of the time.
MEN AND WOMEN FEEL THE CRISIS IN DISTINCTIVE WAYS
Men have born the brunt of the recession so far, accounting for more than three-quarters of job losses. And men are more likely than women to experience job or income loss as a fundamental threat to their identity. But the wives of laid-off men also suffer: Unemployed men are more likely to exhibit hostility towards their partners than unemployed women. Not surprisingly, female partners of unemployed men have higher level of depressive and anxious symptoms than do male partners of unemployed women.
As with previous economic crises, domestic violence has risen. Last year, the National Domestic Violence Hotline reported that calls were up by almost 50 percent over the previous year. A 2009 poll found an increase in domestic violence distress calls at 75 percent of the centers surveyed, most of them related to "financial issues," "stress," and "job loss."
The lower rates of unemployment among women relative to men disguise a crisis for single mothers and their children. According to a Bureau of Labor Statistics report released March 5, 2010, the unemployment rate of single mothers is now 68 percent higher than at the start of the recession. Many single mothers are now struggling to avoid foreclosure, since low-income women, especially women of color, were more likely to be targeted by predatory lenders for subprime mortgages.
Even when they did not take on a mortgage and have not lost their jobs, such women are at risk. The National Low Income Housing Coalition estimates that 40 percent of families facing eviction because of foreclosure are renters, many of them single-mother families.
Unemployment, poverty, and housing insecurity have also risen sharply among married couples with children. As of December 2009, one in seven children was living with a parent who had lost his or her job.
IMPACT ON CHILDREN
Children of economically stressed families often stop looking up to their parents and instead find identity in their peer group. Their motivation to succeed in school and in life can plummet. Teachers reported that children of economically distressed parents are more likely to have behavioral issues. A Chicago study found that children whose mothers experienced unstable employment showed declining levels of self-esteem and proficiency in school.
Children who become homeless are especially at risk, because they tend to miss more school days, which leads them to fall behind academically, and to change schools more often. School relocation is more closely associated with delinquent behavior and academic failure among teens than is family structure.
YOUNG ADULTS AND THE RECESSION
The current recession has also put pressure on young people who are trying to complete their college education. Just as they or their parents are facing income losses, financially strapped states are cutting back on support for higher education and further raising tuition, which was already rising much faster than family income.
In 2009, 37 percent of 18-to-29-year-olds were unemployed or no longer looking for work, and a Pew Survey that year found that 10 percent of people aged 18-34 had moved back in with their parents because of the recession. One national longitudinal study found that people who were unemployed for substantial periods in their teens or early 20s were far more likely to develop depressive symptoms and/or to become heavy drinkers by the time they were middle-aged, regardless of their prior psychological history or drinking patterns.
Young adults who recently graduated from college are not out of the woods, even if they get job offers. Yale economist Lisa Kahn studied the careers of white men who graduated from college between 1979 and 1989. She found that graduates who entered the job market during the 1981-82 recession not only made 25 percent less in their first year than graduates who entered the job market in better times, but continued to earn less than their more fortunate peers even 17 years later.
African-American men face even worse prospects. While the rate of long-term unemployment has grown for all demographic groups, it has grown most sharply for African-American men, who by January 2010 made up just 5.5 percent of the labor force, but 13 percent of the long-term unemployed.
Some people assume that seniors, who have often paid off their houses, are faring relatively well in this recession. But pension plans have been slashed for many retirees, and there are now more than a million people in their 60s and 70s looking for work, a 250 percent increase from two years ago. Seniors who already have jobs are less likely to be laid off than other age groups, but when they do lose their jobs, it takes them 40 percent longer to find a new job than it does the average job seeker. And a report released March 29 by the National Alliance to End Homelessness projects a 33 percent increase over the next decade in elderly people who are homeless.
EFFECTS ON FAMILY RELATIONSHIPS
Positive parent interactions can help alleviate the negative consequences that children suffer due to poverty or financial reverses, but stress and depression erode people's ability to parent effectively. Parents who are worried about their financial stability often do not have the patience to reason with their children or respond to misbehavior appropriately. Feeling frustrated at the seeming ineffectiveness of their first attempt at discipline, they tend to discipline repeatedly, with increasing harshness and in the heat of the moment, which escalates and prolongs parent-child conflict. Stressed parents also find less time to share warm, positive experiences with their children.
Psychologist Joshua Coleman points out that such reactions can occur even in families that remain comparatively secure in the basics of life, but see savings and college education funds slipping away. Stressed parents may fail to recognize that their annoyance with their children may stem from their own anxiety rather than the children's behavior. Feeling guilty about not being able to buy their kids what they want, parents may also behave inconsistently, allowing some misbehavior or whining to succeed, then reacting strongly against the same behavior the next day. Parents should take time to exercise, meditate, do yoga, or just go for a walk with friends, recommends Coleman. "These activities have been shown to decrease anxiety and depression, elevate mood, and increase overall psychological resilience."
Marital relations are also strained by job loss and financial stress. It is sometimes tempting to vent frustrations onto a spouse, believing that he or she will be more forgiving than a stranger. But marriages suffer when negative interactions increase. Psychologist John Gottman reminds us that a marriage needs about 5 positive interactions for every negative one.
MARRIAGE, DIVORCE, AND CHILDBEARING
Divorce rates have been falling modestly but steadily since 1981, and the pace quickened in 2009, with more than half of the lawyers surveyed by the American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers reporting a drop in divorce filings. A few observers have suggested that this is the recession's silver lining. Many of these divorces, however, were postponed only because the couple could not afford to split their assets, not because they were resolving their problems. In some cases, couples continue living together, despite being alienated each other, simply because they cannot afford two separate homes. In these cases, staying together may not be good for either the adults or the children. While a good marriage increases people's immune functioning and lowers their blood pressure, a bad marriage does just the opposite. Children in high conflict marriages generally show fewer behavior and social adjustment problems when their parents separate than when they stay in those high-conflict situations. We know from the experience of the Great Depression of the 1930s that divorce rates can fall while family conflicts and domestic violence rates rise.
After rising from 2003 to 2007, fertility fell slightly in 2008 and then more rapidly in early 2009, according to demographer Steven Martin. A state-by-state analysis of 2008 birth rates released April 6 by the Pew Research Center found that the declines were strongly associated with drops in personal income and housing prices and the percentage of employed workers. Some of the largest declines in fertility occurred in Arizona, California, and Florida, three states especially hard hit by this recession. Although restricting births is economically rational for individual families, when countries fall below replacement fertility, this puts further pressure on pension, health care, and social welfare programs.
HOPE FOR THE FUTURE; RESOURCES FOR NOW
Reaction to the recession has not been all bad. Many families are rethinking their material priorities. Volunteerism is up. Community gardens and other forms of neighborhood cooperation and sharing are on the increase. And some studies show that in the long run people raised in adversity become more sensitive to social inequity and less inclined to blame others for their misfortunes.
But when social adversity is accompanied by marked social inequality, it often leads to resentment and scapegoating. This recession, unlike others, has not yet reduced the huge gulf between the very rich and the rest of Americans, which reached an all-time high in 2007-08, so it is difficult to predict the future of our social climate. In the meantime, we need to be aware of the ongoing threats to individual well-being and family solidarity. Here are some places people can turn for immediate help:
National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 1-800-273-TALK (8255) is a 24 hour hotline that will connect you with a local crisis center in your area.
If someone in your life is hurting you, call the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-SAFE (7233) or TTY 1-800-787-3224.
If you are suffering from alcohol or drug abuse, find a program in your area
If you need a mental health provider
To find a local food bank
If you are concerned about foreclosure
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
Valerie Adrian is a research intern at the Council on Contemporary Families and a senior at The Evergreen State College in Olympia, Washington.
Stephanie Coontz teaches History and Family Studies at The Evergreen State College, serves as Director of Research and Public Education at the Council on Contemporary Families, and is has authored numerous books on American family history and contemporary issues.
American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers. Divorce Filings Have Dropped in the Recession Reveals Survey of Top Matrimonial Lawyers. AAML. American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers, 28 Oct. 2009. Web. <http://www.aaml.org/go/about-the-academy/press/press-releases/ divorce-filings-have-dropped-in-the-recession- reveals-survey-of-top-matrimonial-lawyers/>.
Armour, Stephanie. "Foreclosures Jump in December After Months of Declines." USA Today. Gannett Co. Inc., 14 Jan. 2010. Web. 24 Mar. 2010. <http://www.usatoday.com/money/economy/ housing/2010-01-13-foreclosures-rise-in-december_N.htm>.
Bureau of Labor Statistics Economic News Release, "Unemployed Persons by Duration of Unemployment," April 2, 2010. http://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t12.htm.
Bureau of Labor Statistics Produces Snapshot of African Americans in U.S. Issue Brief. The Center for Family Policy and Practice, Feb. 2010. Web. <http://www.cffpp.org/briefings/brief_1002.html>.
Conger, Rand D., Glen H. Elder, Jr., Frederick O. Lorenz, Katherine J. Conger, Ronald L. Simons, Les B. Whitbeck, Shirley Huck, and Janet N. Melby. "Linking Economic Hardship to Marital Quality and Instability." Journal of Marriage and the Family 52.Aug (1990): 643-56. Print.
DeParle, Jason. "Families Struggle to Afford Food, Survey Finds." The New York Times. The New York Times Company, 26 Jan. 2010. Web. 24 Mar. 2010. <http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/26/us/26food.html>.
Eliason, Marcus, and Donald Storrie. "Does Job Loss Shorten Life?" The Journal of Human Resources 44.2 (2009): 207-302. Print.
Evans, Gary W., and Michelle A. Schamberg. "Childhood Poverty, Chronic Stress, and Adult Working Memory." Proceedings of the Natural Academy of Sciences 106 (2009): 6545-549.
Ginty, Molly M. "In Subprime Fallout, Women Take Heavy Hit | Womens ENews." Women's ENews. Women's Enews, Inc., 14 Jan. 2010. Web. 23 Mar. 2010. <http://www.womensenews.org/story/economyeconomic-policy/ 100113/in-subprime-fallout-women-take-heavy-hit>.
Goodrich, J. "Men May Have It Bad, But Unemployment Statistics Obscure the Hit Taken By Single Moms." AlterNet. 4 Mar. 2010. Web. 24 Mar. 2010. <http://www.alternet.org/economy/145918/men_may_have_it_bad,_but_unemployment_ statistics_obscure_the_hit_taken_by_single_moms>.
Grant, Tim. "Study Finds Median Wealth for Single Black Women at $5." The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. PG Publishing Co., 9 Mar. 2010. Web. 24 Mar. 2010. <http://postgazette.com/pg/10068/1041225-28.stm>.
Greenhouse, Steven. "65 and Up and Looking for Work." The New York Times. The New York Times Company, 24 Oct. 2009. Web. <http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/ 24/business/economy/24older.html>.
Guarino, Mark. "Suburbs: The New Face of America's Poor?" The Christian Science Monitor. 09 Feb. 2010. Web. <http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Society/2010/0209/ Suburbs-The-new-face-of-America-s-poor>.
House Committee on Ways and Means. Ways and Means Examines the Increasing Demand on Food Banks and Charities on the Front-line. Committee on Ways and Means. House Committee on Ways and Means, 19 Nov. 2009. Web. 24 Mar. 2010. <http://waysandmeans.house.gov/press/PRArticle.aspx?NewsID=5626>.
Howe, George W., Mindy L. Levy, and Robert D. Caplan. "Job Loss and Depressive Symptoms in Couples: Common Stressors, Stress Transmission, or Relationship Disruption?" Journal of Family Psychology 18.4 (2004): 639-50. Print.
Huff Stevens, Ann, and Jessamyn Schaller. Short-run Effects of Parental Job Loss on Children's Academic Achievement. Working Paper no. 15480. National Bureau of Economic Research, Nov. 2009. Web. <http://papers.nber.org/papers/w15480>.
Isaacs, Julia B. 2010. "Families of the Recession: Unemployed Parents & Their
Children." Washington, D.C.: The Brookings Institution. Available at: http://www.brookings.edu/pa-pers/2010/0114_families_recession_isaacs.aspx
Kahn, Lisa B. "The Long-Term Labor Market Consequences of Graduating from College in a Bad Economy." Labour Economics 17.2 (2010): 303-16. Print.
Kalil, Ariel, and Kathleen M. Ziol-Guest. "Parental Employment Circumstances and Children's Academic Progress." Social Science Research 37 (2008): 500-15. Print.
Livingston, Gretchen and Cohn, D'Vera, "U.S. Birth Rate Decline Linked to Recession,"
Pew Research Center, April 6, 2010. Web Link.
Luo, Michael, and Megan Thee-Brenan. "Poll Reveals Trauma of Joblessness in U.S." The New York Times. The New York Times Company, 14 Dec. 2009. Web. <http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/15/us/15poll.html>.
Martin, Steven, "New Fertility Trends," March 2010. Web. <http://www.contemporaryfamilies.org/economic-issues/ fertilitytrends.html>.
Mary Kay Inc. World Headquarters. ?Mary Kay?s Truth About Abuse? Survey Links Economic Downturn to National Increase in Domestic Violence. Mary Kay. Mary Kay Ash Charitable Foundation, 12 May 2009. Web. <http://www.pcadv.org/Resources/ MaryKay_Beauty_That_Counts_Release.pdf>.
Misericordia University Healthcare Survey. Publication. The Ketchum Global Research Network. Web. 15 Feb. 2010. <http://www.misericordia.edu/images/news/ Misericordia_Healthcare_Survey_and_Analysis.pdf>.
Mishel, Lawrence, and Jared Bernstein. Economy?s Gains Fail to Reach Most Workers? Paychecks. Issue Brief. Economic Policy Institute, 30 Aug. 2007. Web. 24 Mar. 2010. <http://www.epi.org/publications/entry/bp195/>.
Mistry, Rashmita S., Elizabeth A. Vandewater, Aletha C. Hudson, and Vonnie C. McLoyd. "Economic Well-Being and Children's Social Adjustment: The Role of Family Process in an Ethnically Diverse Low-Income Sample." Child Development 73.3 (2002): 935-51. JSTOR. Web. <http://www.jstor.org/pss/3696260>.
Mossakowski, Krysia. "Is the Duration of Poverty and Unemployment a Risk Factor for Heavy Drinking?" Social Science and Medicine 67.6 (2008): 947-55. Print.
Mossakowski, Krysia. "The Influence of Past Unemployment Duration on Symptoms of Depression among Young Women and Men in the United States." American Journal of Public Health 99.10 (2009): 1826-832. Print.
Murray, Sara, and Betsy McKay. "Early Data Suggests Suicides Are Rising." The Wall Street Journal. Dow Jones and Company, 23 Nov. 2009. Web. <http://online.wsj.com/article/ SB125892118623059701.html?mod=WSJ_hpp_MIDDLTopStories>.
"One in 7 U.S. Mortgages Foreclosing or Delinquent." Reuters. 19 Nov. 2009. Web. <http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE5AI38320091119>.
Peck, Don. "How a New Jobless Era Will Transform America." The Atlantic. The Atlantic Monthly Group, Mar. 2010. Web. <http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2010/03/ how-a-new-jobless-era-will-transform-america/7919/>.
"Realtytrac® Year-End Report Shows Record 2.8 Million U.S. Properties With Foreclosure Filings In 2009." Foreclosure Real Estate Listings | RealtyTrac. RealtyTrac, 14 Jan. 2010. Web. 24 Mar. 2010. <http://www.realtytrac.com/contentmanagement/ pressrelease.aspx?itemid=8333>
Reckdahl, Katy. "Food Banks See Demand Increasing, Nationwide and in New Orleans." The Times-Picayune. New Orleans Net LLC., 9 Feb. 2010. Web. 24 Mar. 2010. <http://www.nola.com/news/index.ssf/2010/02/ food_banks_see_demand_increasi.html>.
Reynolds, Arthur J., Chin-Chih Chen, and Janette E. Herbers. School Mobility and Educational Success: A Research Synthesis and Evidence on Prevention. Rep. The Foundation for Child Development, 22 June 2009. Web. <http://www.fcd-us.org/usr_doc/ ReynoldsSchoolMobilityAndEducationalSuccess.pdf>.
Roberts, Sam. "Facing a Financial Pinch, and Moving in with Mom and Dad." New York Times. 21 March, 2010.
Schiavocampo, Mara. "More Women Becoming Sole Breadwinners -." The Daily Nightly - Msnbc.com. 6 Mar. 2009. Web. <http://dailynightly.msnbc.msn.com/archive/2009/03/ 06/1824665.aspx>.
Stein, Rob. "Research Links Poor Kids' Stress, Brain Impairment." Washington Post. 6 April 2009
Sullivan, Daniel, and Till Von Wachter. Job Displacement and Mortality: An Analysis Using Administrative Data. Working Paper no. 13626. National Bureau of Economic Research, Nov. 2007. Web. <http://www.columbia.edu/~vw2112/papers/ sullivan_vonwachter_resubmission.pdf>.
Turning Point: The Long Term Effects Of Recession-Induced Child Poverty. Rep. First Focus, May 2009. Web. <http://www.firstfocus.net/Download/ TurningPoint.pdf>.
Wade, Lisa. "Guest Post: Recession, Resilience, Divorce?" Web Log post. Sociological Images. 4 Jan. 2010. Web. 4 Jan. 2010. <http://contexts.org/socimages/2010/01/04/ guest-post-recession-resilience-divorce/>.
Wistrom, Brent. "Report: More seniors to be homeless by 2020." The Wichita Eagle, March 30, 2010/
"Why Are People Homeless?" National Coalition for the Homeless. July 2009. Web. <http://www.nationalhomeless.org/factsheets/why.html>.
Wilcox, W. Bradford. "The Great Recession's Silver Lining? 2009." The State of Our Unions. 2009. Web. <http://www.stateofourunions.org/ 2009/great_recession.php>.
CCF is a volunteer organization whose busy professionals contribute their time and expertise gratis. Click here to support our mission by making a donation to CCF. Your contributions will help to fund our annual conferences and publicize our research briefings.